Tuesday, February 11, 2014

Review: Maybe One Day by Melissa Kantor

I can't decide if I like this cover or the original better?
This one depicts the girls pretty accurately but there's no beach in the book...
★★★★☆

Before you read this book, disregard everything you think you know about cancer diagnosis and treatment. I'm not saying the book is one hundred percent inaccurate, but I've seen a lot of reviews complaining about how "unrealistic" it is, and I think it's best to go in with an open mind. The book isn't about the cancer, the diagnosis or the treatment-- it's about two childhood best friends going through it together. Because even though only one of them has cancer, they are both going through it. And that's kind of the point.
The Author's Note clearly states that in any instances where she had to choose between medical accuracy and the story itself, she chose the story. As the author, that's kind of her job, and as readers, I think it's kind of our job to respect that.

Olivia and Zoe have been best friends since they were tiny children (I don't remember how old, exactly). They have always done everything together, including going to and getting dropped from a prestigious dance school. They know each other's wardrobes, practically live at each other's houses, and consider each other members of their family. Every important thing that's ever happened to them has happened not to Olivia or to Zoe, but to Olivia and Zoe.
Including Olivia's cancer.
Narrated by Zoe, Maybe One Day is partly a reflection on a lifelong friendship, and partly a struggle with reality: that the "forever" in "best friends forever" isn't always as long as it should be.
Let me make one thing clear on the "reality" front for a second. This book isn't action-packed, there isn't anything overtly exciting about it, and there isn't a sweep-you-off-your-feet-never-leave-the-ground-again romance. It's about living your day-to-day life when you're a teenager whose best friend has cancer, and you're still trying to figure out what extracurricular activity you want to do. If you've ever watched Friday Night Lights, you know that sometimes "real" doesn't mean "boring." Humanity at its most regular and normal can be some of the most interesting stories you'll ever find, and that is what's great about this book. I was completely absorbed in Zoe and Olivia's friendship, and I was only occasionally bothered by the lack of attention given to the romance (which only bothered me not because it made the romance less important, but because the times when Zoe's relationship with Calvin was the main focus, it seemed like insta-love. Like there was no real connection between them other than a crush under development). The story of these two girls and their lives together I think will hit home with a lot of people-- it will strike a chord because this is the kind of friendship some people have always been jealous of, or because they will find themselves in it. It was a little bit of both for me. 

And I really loved Zoe's relationships with everyone, not just Olivia. She's like a sister to Olivia's brother, Jake, and very much not like a daughter to Olivia's parents. I thought that relationship with her best friend's parents was important, because it was realistic; I've experienced it myself. That nagging feeling that your friend's parents don't like you, that maybe even they wish it were you who had cancer instead of their daughter. Why wouldn't they? But how is Zoe supposed to deal with that? Being treated like an outsider when you've felt like a part of the family for so long is going to have unforseen emotional consequences; Zoe is bitter a lot of the time, and she lashes out at her own parents. But their friendship dictates that it doesn't matter, and she's always there for Olivia. In the end, the fact that Olivia's parents didn't think of her as their adoptive daughter was not important, because Olivia was. 
Her relationship with Calvin was not the main focus of the story, but I think it helped move it along. It helped Zoe deal with a lot of things, provided a bit of well-needed tension, and wasn't entirely boring. Calvin is vaguely swoon-worthy and a truly good person, so I can't really complain here.

Especially since this book isn't pitched as a romance, nor should it be. It's about friendship.

So yes, Maybe One Day is a tearjerker, and you can probably guess why. But it will also make you nostalgic, and angry, and happy, and hopeful. To reduce it to how many buckets of tears you shed while reading it would be a tremendous disservice.

Review: Crown of Midnight by Sarah J. Maas

✭✭✭✭½

I'm starting this review at 12:27am. This is a bad idea for several reasons:

  1. I'm at my most emotional when a) I've just finished a book, or b) it's past midnight. So, double whammy.
  2. A book like this, my review is going to be long and rambly and I probably won't finish it until at least 2:00 if I do the whole thing now.
  3. I was totally ready to start another book, and if I keep dwelling on this one I'm going to have such a bad book hangover that I won't be able to do it. I just won't.
Crap, guys.
Crap.
I wasn't prepared for this book. It beckoned me to float into the sky and then it beat me down, and beat me down, and beat me down some more.
Right, this is supposed to be the part where I tell you how much you'll enjoy Crown of Midnight. Lucky for you, "beat me down" in my vocabulary tends to mean "got me emotionally invested to the point where I cry when the characters are sad, I cry when they're happy, I cry when their full names are used in butt-kicking, odds-defying moments, and I cry when their expectations of each other are just a little too high." Because that's what happens when you love someone: you expect too much of them. You get hurt, and you hurt them right back.

Let's talk about Celaena Sardothien, the King's Champion, for a second.
Celaena, whose family was slaughtered, whose best friend and first love was murdered, who spent a year in a salt mine prison and then whose one chance for freedom involved a tournament to the death. This girl isn't just followed by death, she is death. Psychologically damaged to the point where you're on edge constantly, waiting for her to break, Celaena is not your average Strong Female Character. And I'm not talking about the padded-room-with-a-straitjacket kind of break, or the eat-your-sorrows-and-cry-in-your-bed kind of break. I'm talking about the kill-now-think-later kind of break. There are a lot of kickass female protagonists that could make you regret being born, but Celaena wouldn't even give you long enough to do so. She's an assassin, and you do not want to cross her.
It's not easy to forget how deadly Celaena is, and yet a few people have managed to see past it. Chaol, Dorian and Nehemia haven't forgotten what she is, but they're more concerned with who she is. Her relationships with each of them are extremely different, but they all ring true-- and that is why I loved this book. Through all the court drama, politics, fighting and magic, it shines with authentic humanity, with connections that sometimes break and can't grow back the way they were before, but they do grow back.
I spent a lot of time in this book arguing with myself. Part of me was mad at Celaena for the way she acted, how quickly she could turn on the people who cared about her, but then the another part of me was constantly reminding myself that she had a history of being betrayed-- and that she's suffered horrible trauma at the command of the king she now serves. And she's a teenage girl. All things considered, I think she's allowed to be irrational, spiteful and reckless. Not even halfway through the series, we have reason to believe that she's not irreparably damaging herself by being this way. Even within this very book she realizes her mistake and admits it. In the next one, maybe she won't be so impulsive or see things in such black and white terms.
Now, moving away from Celaena to talk about the book in general, I thought it was just brilliant. The transition from romance to friendship with Dorian was extremely well done and I didn't find myself doubting for a second that they could be friends. Dorian Havilliard, the Crown Prince of Adarlan, could pretty much have any girl he wanted. He wants the King's Champion, but she is the one person it seems doesn't want him back-- and what does he do? He handles it with such grace and dignity that I grew to love him even more than I already did (and I swear to god, Sarah J. Maas, I'm keeping him locked away in my room until you promise not to hurt him. I have a lot of books he can read). Dorian Havilliard is who Adam Kent should have been, but was never a decent enough human to be.
Celaena's relationship with Chaol-- Chaol Westfall, Captain of the Guard, loyal servant to the king he suspects Celaena wants to see dead-- comes naturally. The stakes are high and you could cut the tension with a knife, but one thing is always abundantly clear: Celaena and Chaol will always choose each other. They are natural enemies who learn to live in the space between right and wrong. Emotional punches left, right, up and down; don't ever get used to things going well. This book doesn't want you to be able to stand. 
You might notice that I'm talking more about the characters and relationships than anything else about the book, which may seem like a normal thing for me as those are what I usually care about the most. Honestly, though, I'm not talking about the other stuff because I slogged through it. The action scenes were compelling enough, but the magic/dungeon/exploring the castle scenes, not so much. They felt redundant and were often too long to keep me interested. I still don't find the magic the most interesting part of the series. Luckily, it's worth reading for everything else.
The writing in Crown of Midnight is leaps above what it was in Throne of Glass. Any chapter- or section-ending sentence that started with "Celaena Sardothien" or "The King's Champion" or "The Captain of the Guard" was like an emotional bomb being dropped on the page. And that final sentence? Like I said: Crap. The whole final page? Holy. Crap.

I need Heir of Fire (the revelation that explains that title? Oh yes. Yes yes yes.) right now. 

Wednesday, February 5, 2014

Review: Ignite Me by Tahereh Mafi


★★★★★

Seriously, if you haven't given this series a chance yet, you really, really ought to do so. Ignore the Goodreads reviewers' complaints about prose. I get where they're coming from, and I can tell you right now those people are only hurting themselves by not giving Tahereh Mafi the benefit of the doubt. Because character development. The prose in the first book is meant to reflect who Juliette was at that point, and she is not that girl anymore.

This review is going to contain spoilers for Shatter Me and Unravel me, so if you have not read those yet, please read them now. I'll wait.




Okay, ready?
So. Ignite Me picks up after Juliette has broken both Adam's and Warner's hearts and been shot by their father. She finds out that Omega Point has been destroyed and everyone in it is dead. Well, almost everyone. We're supposed to assume that there's a very small chance Adam and Kenji and the rest made it out alive, but we all know better, right? Adam's out there, still crying like a baby because Juliette broke up with him or because he thinks she's dead (dude is never satisfied, amirite) and Kenji's out there with him, telling him how annoying all his drama is.
And Juliette is with Warner. Who saved her life, even though she broke his heart.
Man, this book was everything I wanted it to be. Of all the trilogies that have ended in the past year, this one had the most satisfying ending. Honestly, it's the first series-ender since Reached that didn't give me that feeling where my stomach drops and my blood runs cold because I've just realized it's not going to end how I wanted it to end. I mean, it had about the same effect as Requiem-- which I know most people hated (they're all a bunch of know-nothing Jon Snows if you ask me)-- everything just built up and built up to a place that made sense, that didn't try to make the reader feel like an idiot for wanting a happy ending. Sure, it's not a happy ending for everyone, but all in all it's much happier than it could have been.
Why?
Because of Juliette Ferrars.
She thinks in mostly normal sentences. She doesn't cross out her thoughts. She stands up for herself, and for everyone else. She's done wallowing in self-pity and she's done letting her power control her. She's learning to control it, in more ways than one.
I'm trying not to give away too much since the book just came out yesterday, so I'll just say this: she realizes that one relationship is wrong for her. And she finds herself with two right ones (not necessarily romantic).
And stuff.
Goes.
Down.

This book is perfectly paced, has consistent humor balanced well with all the angst, and anyone who complained of insta-love in the first book is going to be ridiculously pleased with this one. There's not a dull moment in the entire book, but really the thing most worth talking about is the character development. And not just Juliette's. Adam's, Warner's, Kenji's (keep in mind that not all character development is good development). I want to write amusing songs about their relationships with each other. Also, move over Adji (Kendam?), there's a new brotp in town. More of a reluctant, nervous-laughter brotp, but it makes me so, so happy.
In fact, here's a spoiler-lite list of things about this book that make me happy:
  • Kenji (◕‿◕✿)
  • No crossouts ʘ‿ʘ 
  • Warner being serious (◡‿◡✿)
  • Warner joking (✿◠‿◠)
  • Nobody understanding Warner's sense of humor (╹◡╹)
  • Juliette being a badass (◕‿-)
  • A certain "unidentified roadkill" comment (◑‿◐)
  • Chapter 55 (✿ ♥‿♥)
  • James 。◕ ‿ ◕。
  • Juliette telling Warner what to do (~ ̄▽ ̄)~
  • "Two hundred and sixty-four days I was in there and the whole time, I had the power to break myself out and I didn't, because I had no idea I would. Because I never even tried. Because I let the world teach me to hate myself. I was a coward, who needed someone else to tell me I was worth something before I took any steps to save myself." ᕙ(⇀‸↼‶)ᕗ
  • JULIETTE FERRARS TAKING CONTROL OF HER OWN GOSHDARN LIFE (。♥‿♥。)
Let's recall that I gave Shatter Me 2 stars.
And then I gave Unravel Me 4 stars.
Well, she's finally done it.
I'm giving Ignite Me 5 stars, and I feel good about it.

Tuesday, February 4, 2014

Double Review: Ava Lavender & Geography

I haven't written an actual review in a while, so I figured it was time. I'll make this a two-review post, though, because I have two books I want to review and not a whole lot to say about either of them. This is not necessarily a bad thing, because one is getting a good review and one is getting a mediocre review.


First up: The Strange and Beautiful Sorrows of Ava Lavender by Leslye Walton
★★★★★
Source: Galley from Candlewick
Plot overview from Goodreads:
Foolish love appears to be the Roux family birthright, an ominous forecast for its most recent progeny, Ava Lavender. Ava—in all other ways a normal girl—is born with the wings of a bird. In a quest to understand her peculiar disposition and a growing desire to fit in with her peers, sixteen-year old Ava ventures into the wider world, ill-prepared for what she might discover and naïve to the twisted motives of others. Others like the pious Nathaniel Sorrows, who mistakes Ava for an angel and whose obsession with her grows until the night of the Summer Solstice celebration. That night, the skies open up, rain and feathers fill the air, and Ava’s quest and her family’s saga build to a devastating crescendo. First-time author Leslye Walton has constructed a layered and unforgettable mythology of what it means to be born with hearts that are tragically, exquisitely human.
My coworker put this book in my mailbox in, like, October, and I didn't touch it until last week. I don't know why. I mean, magical realism! That's my thing! I knew it was going to be good-- she's got good taste, this coworker of mine, but her taste is so very different from mine that she hardly ever makes recommendations for me. So if she thinks we'll *both* like a book? Well.
The Strange and Beautiful Sorrows of Ava Lavender is a novelty of narration, if you ask me. It's told by Ava Lavender in a strange and beautiful omniscient first person. Omniscient first person? But how? And before you ask, no, she's not psychic. You see, Ava tells this story as kind of a research paper on her family. She starts all the way back with her great-grandparents, and through her we get to know every member of her family from that generation until her own. Her reflective voice doesn't lend itself much to dialogue, and the chapters are rather long, but there's a magic woven into this book that makes it fly by. The style is thought-provoking and leaves little nuggets of foreshadowing and parallelism that will thoroughly please both YA and adult readers (there's an argument to be made that this book shouldn't be marketed as YA but, rather, as an adult book, but I take offense to that idea. Young adult readers are perfectly capable of appreciating a book like this, and adult readers will just have to get rid of their prejudices against YA literature and read it without being catered to. If they don't, it's their loss.)
I can't say enough about the characters, either. None of them are characterized in that exaggerated-yet-subtle way that I love so much, but the focus here is more on their stories than their personalities-- and rightfully so. Emilienne Roux/Lavender has evaded love since it destroyed her family. Viviane Lavender has spent her life waiting for her first love to come back to her. And Ava Lavender? She's been hiding from a world that could never let her be what she wants to be: normal.
Because she was born with wings, and everyone will be afraid.
Because everyone else was born without wings, and she's afraid.
If you were looking for a book about one protagonist, look somewhere else. This is a book about a whole family, the way their hearts bind them and set them free, the way a family is a family no matter what it looks like. It's about people who are broken, keeping themselves together. It's about the strange and beautiful nature of love in all its forms-- foolish, catastrophic, innocent, destructive, familial, pure, obsessive, misguided, restorative love.
And finally, the prose. I would say it might be the best thing about this book, but I truly can't decide. I'll just say the prose is lyrical, like a mix between Lauren Oliver's style in Delirium and Markus Zusak's in The Book Thief. At the same time, it's something all its own. Here, have some quotes if you don't believe me:
"She spent her days trying to forget the sound of his voice, and her nights trying to remember."
Don't you feel like you just got slapped in the face?
"And that might just be the root of the problem: we're all afraid of each other, wings or no wings."
If you don't want to read this book by now, I can't help you. But I can leave you one more quote:
"Fate. As a child, that word was often my only companion. It whispered to me from dark corners during lonely nights. It was the song of the birds in spring and the call of the wind through bare branches on a cold winter afternoon. Fate. Both my anguish and my solace. My escort and my cage."


Next up: The Geography of You and Me by Jennifer E. Smith
★★½
Source: e-galley from Hachette
Plot overview from Goodreads:
Lucy and Owen meet somewhere between the tenth and eleventh floors of a New York City apartment building, on an elevator rendered useless by a citywide blackout. After they're rescued, they spend a single night together, wandering the darkened streets and marveling at the rare appearance of stars above Manhattan. But once the power is restored, so is reality. Lucy soon moves to Edinburgh with her parents, while Owen heads out west with his father.
Lucy and Owen's relationship plays out across the globe as they stay in touch through postcards, occasional e-mails, and -- finally -- a reunion in the city where they first met.
A carefully charted map of a long-distance relationship, Jennifer E. Smith's new novel shows that the center of the world isn't necessarily a place. It can be a person, too.
Okay, I'll try to keep this short since the first review was longer than I expected. To be quite honest, I was disappointed with this book. Usually I fly through Smith's books in a few hours and feel totally satisfied with the experience, but this time something was missing.
I think it's my sister's fault.
When she read The Statistical Probability of Love at First Sight and This is What Happy Looks Like, my sister pointed out how much these books would benefit from being told in first person rather than third. I was taken aback, because I've always loved that they were written in third. But why?
I think I only liked it because it was different. Most contemporary romances like this are written in first, and therefore these ones are automatically set apart. But I've come to realize that there's a reason those ones are written in first-person: we need to feel attached to at least one of the characters.
Don't get me wrong, I cared enough about Lucy and Owen to keep reading, but something stopped me from fully buying into their story. I was keenly aware of the third person this time around, and felt like it distanced me from them-- especially when weeks or months took place between chapters and they had to update me on their lives. As the reader, I don't think I should feel like I need to be updated on the main characters' lives. In one chapter, Lucy's meeting a new guy, and in the next chapter she's been dating him long enough to casually attend his rugby games as the supportive girlfriend. When did that happen?
Something about all the traveling in this book made me uncomfortable, too. Both of the characters were extremely attached to their homes before their lives were uprooted, and I didn't feel enough of the homesickness. Owen's father allowing him to move from school to school in his senior year as they traveled by car across the country was not only irresponsible but seemed inauthentic to his character: I simply don't believe that he would have done it. I don't believe that Owen would instantaneously feel detached from his childhood home when his mother died, or that he would refuse to love New York and then open his heart to every single other city they moved to. I don't believe that Lucy felt anything for the cities she visited or lived in with her parents, because I was only given tourist reasons to enjoy those cities. When Lucy was talking about New York, she could go off about her memories and the idiosyncrasies of the elevator for an entire paragraph, and that's what made it home. There was nothing like that for Edinburgh or London, both of which she seemed to accept as her home way too quickly.
My last gripe is that a lot of what I loved about Smith's previous books was that the main characters spent so much time together and getting to know each other-- even if it was just a plane ride, Hadley and Oliver had a chemistry that I couldn't put my finger on-- and Lucy and Owen did not. They had one night, and then postcards. Postcards, where you can write maybe five lines at a time (and they never took up all five lines). If they had ever used the word "love" with each other, I would have said it reeked of, dare I say it, insta-love.
All of this said, I'm giving the book 2.5 stars because, well, it had its moments. I liked the references (Bartleby!) and the characters weren't bad, nor was the plot per sé. I just felt like it focused too much on the characters' histories and issues and not enough on who they are, and why they're right for each other. 
I could round up and give this 3 stars, but I'd prefer not to.

Sunday, December 29, 2013

Favorites: 2013 Edition


It's time. As I start this post, 2013 has approximately three days left. I need to choose.
This list will be like my list last year: all YA, ranked from last to first, with my favorite book of the year being number 1. That one is easy. The rest... well, we'll see how many I end up with this year. Last year it was 16, but this year I read literally twice as many books. So, yeah.

[update: I ended up with 19 20. Tee... hee.]
[update #2: Also, they're all by female authors, accidentally. I tried to find books by male authors to add, but it turns out I didn't read very many of those this year. Which is something I should/might work on next year, but probably I'll just keep reading what I want to read, regardless of authorial gender.]

20. Unravel Me by Tahereh Mafi
Okay, so here's the thing about the Shatter Me series: the prose of the first book is purposefully awful-- the key word here being purposefully. Tahereh Mafi has known her main character's development since the beginning, and she's been writing it into the very way the character speaks to the reader. So if you're thinking about checking out this series, DO NOT LISTEN to the reviewers on Goodreads who complain excessively about the prose. It gets better-- by which I mean it sounds less like you're in the head of a mental patient having an existential crisis-- in the second book. And it will get even better than that in the third. And Juliette's not the only one who gets character development in this book; in fact, I'm pretty sure Tahereh was just walking around inside her own head, swinging a giant "character development" club. No one was spared. (Well, except Adam. Who was apparently hit on the head with something harder and less useful than a Character Development Club.)

19. Altered by Jennifer Rush
This is a breath of fresh air in the dystopian genre, if you could even say it falls into that category. There's weird stuff going on and it's definitely not the world we live in, but it's a lot like it. It's our world, but with a secret pocket of sciencey people who are up to no good. And the characters are capital G Great.

18. Between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea by April Genevieve Tucholke
So if you remember my review of this book, you'll remember that I felt like it was written for me. I mean, gothic-ish cliffside town? Moral ambiguity? Easily
paired with a specific song by the Civil Wars? Sign me up. Honestly the fact that this only made it to number 18 is more a comment on the other books than it is on this one. Just you wait.

17. This is What Happy Looks Like by Jennifer E. Smith
I'm a sucker for Jennifer E. Smith, what can I say. Third-person contemporary romances are hard to come by, and I eat hers up like my morning cereal (which is to say, fast. I inhale food in the morning).

16. Across a Star-Swept Sea by Diana Peterfreund
I mean, the main character is a socialite-slash-disguised-hero with a pet sea otter named Slipstream. You do the math.

15. Golden by Jessi Kirby
I think this book came to me at the exact time when I would most identify with
its main character, Parker. It's a heart-stealing combination of love, mystery and poetry, that shows us the choices to be made when ambition doesn't meet up with expectation, when you're stuck between childhood and adulthood, or even when you just don't know where to go from here. From what I can tell, this book has been special to everyone who has read it.


14. The Beginning of Everything by Robyn Schneider
A perfect book for a year with no new John Green novels, and what is quite possibly the YA book that most successfully balanced humor and tragedy this year. I wasn't even bitter that it gave me a sunburn.

13. These Broken Stars by Amy Kaufman and Meagan Spooner
Again, the word that immediately comes to mind is "sparkly." I don't know what's wrong with my brain, that it can't come up with a better word for this fantastic book. There are starships and strange planets and invisible creatures and a good, solid romance and a female character who sees our societal demand for Strong Female Characters and raises us the acknowledgment that "Strong" and "Weak" are not mutually exclusive, as well as a male character who sees the Tough Soldier trope and raises us a happy-- not painful-- backstory and a whole lot of caring. Competence abounds, in both the characters and the authors.

12. Just One Day / Just One Year by Gayle Forman
Yeah, yeah, yeah, they're two books. But they both came out this year, and they're about the same characters, so get over it. Just One Day is my favorite of the two, but they're both the thoughtful, romantic, character-driven books we've come to expect from Gayle Forman. And trust me, there's never going to be a year when Gayle has a new book out and I don't put her on this list.

11. Night of Cake & Puppets by Laini Taylor
Okay, so I know Laini had an ~actual book~ out this year and that this is just a novella, but CONFESSION: I haven't gotten around to reading Days of Blood and Starlight yet, though I had Laini sign my copy at LeakyCon. You see, I could confidently have her sign and personalize it for me because I know I'll love it and will therefore keep it. But I did read Night of Cake & Puppets, and let me tell you, it's adorable. Zuzana is one of my favorite characters in the history of ever, and the magic sprinkled throughout the story is just delicious, as is Laini's writing. Just perfect.

10. The Coldest Girl in Coldtown by Holly Black
Usually a Holly Black book would be way up there on my list, but CONFESSION #2: I grow weary of new takes on vampire mythology. Luckily for me, the originality of this one outweighs the ennui I'm feeling with the genre. Holly is a plot wizard who dallies in compelling characters and fascinating worlds. The end.

9. Never Fade by Alexandra Bracken
If I had had half a brain last year, I would have read The Darkest Minds before the year was up and included it in my Best of 2012 List. But alas, I did not read it until I'd secured an eARC of this, book 2 in the series. Double whammy. One of the best dystopian series out there-- yes, better than Divergent; no, not as good as The Hunger Games are you crazy-- Never Fade is nonstop action, drama and character development throughout. Psychological thriller, dystopia, romance, paranormal, action, this series has ALL THE FACETS.

8. Eleanor & Park / Fangirl by Rainbow Rowell
I cannot choose, and you cannot make me. If you haven't read Eleanor & Park yet, I don't know what the heck you are waiting for. My coworker recommends it to everyone who likes John Green, but I would like to add everyone who likes Gayle Forman, Stephanie Perkins and/or David Levithan to that list. The same goes for Fangirl, but more specifically for those who have ever been... well, fangirls.

7. The Madness Underneath by Maureen Johnson
I'm still not over it.
Because.
STEPHEN.
[Read this series right now because misery loves company and also because it's great ok bye]

6. Siege and Storm by Leigh Bardugo
The fact that this series provides a villain who is so endlessly fascinating that people mistake him for a love interest, and yet who REMAINS A VILLAIN, just basically shows you what an excellent writer Leigh Bardugo is. I mean, you've got Alina, the female main character who comes into this intense and consuming power but who is also the main source of comic relief; you've got Mal, the adorable, competent, puppydog friend [slash ACTUAL love interest], who may be unflinchingly loyal but at the same time he's not willing to sit around and wait while Alina makes her decisions; and you've got the Darkling, who I mentioned before. And in this installment, we get Sturmhond the Magnificent (or, that's what I call him in my head. Starting now)! Add in this Russian-inspired fantasy world and it's just a win-win-win for everyone and there's no pain or feelings and you definitely won't cry or throw things or feel like you want to take over a country.
Oh, wait.

5. How to Love by Katie Cotugno
This is not a great book for a debut novel. It's a great book, period. This is how contemporary romances with heavy subject matters should be done. Sawyer and Reena are characters whose lives mattered to me in a very short amount of time, and I didn't want to leave them by the time the book was over. My Harper rep at work said it was recommended to her but she was afraid to read it because she had it in her head that it would be another beachy summer romance to be housed in the YA/Pop Culture section. No. No, no, no. It's not depressing; it's emotional. It's not light; it's entertaining. It's both, and it's wonderful.

4. Requiem by Lauren Oliver 
This book was the redemption I was hoping for after Pandemonium. Still flawless, poetic, subtle yet forceful writing, but this time things happened. Also: Lena, Alex (!), Hana. The actual perfect ending to this series, no matter what anyone says (but really, it pains me that this book has such a low rating on Goodreads because some people are spoiled and didn't get exactly what they wanted. Learn the value in telling the right story, people, instead of just the story you think should be told.)


3. Untold by Sarah Rees Brennan
She did it again. I stayed up until 3:30am to finish this book, and then when I did, there was no one around to hear my wails. Sarah has established her Basic Trilogy Outline, which determines that Book 2 is the Make-Out Book. And oh, was it. First, there was a raging sea of angst. Then, finally, my ship found land. It was happy. We bounded, my ship and I, through fields of bliss and magic (not to be confused with evil sorcery, which I will get to in a few seconds). Nothing could stop us now!
And then.
She did.
The thing.
You know, the thing. That she does. With the characters. And the evil. And the torment. And Jared, always Jared. My heart weeps for you, damaged Lynburn boy. Someday, this world will turn your way. (I lie to him to ease his incessant pain.)

2. Clockwork Princess by Cassandra Clare
Speaking of incessant pain. I waited for this book for so long. It felt longer than it was, just because of how badly I wanted it. What I didn't know was that I didn't want it, not really. I didn't want this story to end, and I definitely didn't want to let go of Will Herondale the way I had to let go of him (read: I actually still haven't). I didn't think I would ever not be bitter about that epilogue, but I've grown to accept it. Cassie truly outdid herself with this book. The writing, the attention to detail, the way every loose end is tied up in a bittersweet bow-- but most of all, the characters. Everything they did, every decision they made in Clockwork Princess was true and believable to me, as someone who feels like I have lived with these characters for a significant portion of my life, even though it's only been the past few years. The obvious takeaway from this book is about the possibility of loving more than one person, but honestly, for me, this series has always been about the importance of stories to people like me. People like Will and Tessa and even Jem, who tells stories with his songs. And though it will hurt, I'll read this one again and again.


*****drumroll*****


1. The Dream Thieves by Maggie Stiefvater
Alright, yeah, you all saw this coming. This is, obviously, by far, my favorite series-- I mean, it's so far ahead of any of the others that late at night, when I have a stack of books sitting in front of me, begging to be read, I sense them eyeing me with disdain because oh, what do you know, I've picked up The Raven Boys again. Or The Dream Thieves. And the problem is that I kind of can't even say what about this book is so great, other than the writing in general and every character in particular, because that would require describing what the book is about. Which is something that stands so close to impossible that impossible can only see one of its eyes at a time. So close that the author herself can barely manage it, and instead uses catchwords like "dead Welsh king" and "exploding cars" and "prep school boys" and "psychics behaving badly" before launching into a long explanation of new character Kavinsky-- who's bad news, to put it mildly. Anyway, these books are my favorite because the narration is pitch-perfect and sneaks into your head, turning the characters on paper into actual living people inside your mind, and this fictional place into a place you feel like you could visit in real life. They're my favorite because every character (if you haven't noticed by now that character is the most important thing for me, there is no hope for you) is authentic and three-dimensional and complicated in their own way, and their relationships follow suit. They're my favorite because they're not plot-driven, but there is still a compelling plot. I cannot say enough about these books or their author, so I'm just going to spare you and stop gushing now.

Ah, there you have it. 2013.
Some already confirmed for next year: We Were Liars by E. Lockhart and Panic by Lauren Oliver.

Thursday, December 26, 2013

Review: Being Sloane Jacobs by Lauren Morrill


Anyone remember my review of Meant to Be? How I gave it 3 stars because I felt pretty strongly that the main character was completely disagreeable? And the plot holes? And the generally unsatisfying nature of the drama?
Well, the strange thing is that I'm giving Lauren Morrill's second book the same rating, but none of those problems existed in this one. It's like she fixed those but left out the things that I actually liked about Meant to Be at the same time.

Being Sloane Jacobs is about two girls with the same name-- Sloane Jacobs, as you probably guessed. Sloane Devon Jacobs is a hockey player with an injured knee and a mom in rehab, and Sloane Emily Jacobs is a figure skater who's been out of competition for a while and has just discovered the stereotypical scandal that could ruin her father's senatorial career. They both have things to run from, so that's what they do. After running into each other at a hotel in Canada-- each of the Sloanes on their way to skating-related summer camp-- they decide to switch places. So it's Sloane Devon who's off to a prestigious figure skating camp, and Sloane Emily who's off to play hockey for the summer.

And that's basically it. There are minor subplots, but not much serves to keep your attention here. It seemed like, with twice as many characters, the details of each character were cut in half. If my problem with Meant to Be was that I felt too strongly against Julia, my problem with Being Sloane Jacobs was that I didn't feel strongly enough about either Sloane. They could have both been the kind of exaggerated characters that I love, but their differences ended up being very on-the-surface, and then even those got whittled down until they were practically the same person. And their love interests were not interesting in the least-- definitely no Jason Lippincott/Logan Echolls equivalent to be found here.

Oh, and yet more phone-related plot holes persist in this one, too! Like, why would it be an issue that Sloane Emily's parents might call Sloane Devon while they were switched? Was there some kind of landline in the BSI room, or...? It was never really explained, and the moment Sloane Devon got that call I was taken out of the story trying to figure out why it happened.

Another reviewer on Goodreads compared this book to a Disney Channel original movie, and I feel like this hits the nail on the head. It's decent entertainment even if the switching-places plot is a little tired, and you don't really *have* to get attached to the characters to enjoy it. But personally, I want to get attached. I'd prefer to keep going because I want the characters to be okay, not just because I know they will be eventually and I want to get there faster.

All of this said, I'm convinced that someday, Lauren Morrill is going to write a book I absolutely love. I can tell she has it in her. I just think it's a matter of finding the right story, the one that no one else can tell better.
★★★☆☆

Monday, November 18, 2013

Review: The Summer I Found You


So, I've spent the last four hours reading this entire book and wondering a few things: 
  1. Is it Aidan or Aiden? (Seriously? This is so obvious it's not even Writing 101. It's like Common Sense 101: You should know how to spell your own character's name.)
  2. Did this book not have betas? Because it has legitimately the worst grammar and punctuation I've seen in any book, ever. Someone teach Jolene Perry how to use a comma... and apostrophes... and question marks... and proper sentence structure (e.g. "I'm one of the girls who roll her eyes every day they wear their cute little uniforms." This sentence should be either referring to the speaker herself: "I'm one of the girls who rolls her eyes..." or referring to 'the girls' as a group: "I'm one of the girls who roll their eyes..." And I'm not just being picky here; there were so many sentences with such poor wording that I had to read them twice or three times just to figure out what they were trying to say). I realize that what I read was a galley and all of this could be fixed by the time the final version is published, but I sincerely doubt it. Galleys should not have even been sent out with the book in this condition. You know that feeling that you used to get in high school when you had to critique someone else's paper, and all you wanted to do was rewrite every other sentence to make it flow better and actually, you know, follow the rules of the English language? That was how I felt throughout this whole book. 
  3. What is with that cover? It's not relevant to the book at all. Neither, for that matter, is the title. The book does not even take place in the summer. It takes place during the school year, because how else would we have been forced to sit through the *totally* traumatic experience of seeing Kate's ex-boyfriend with his stereotypical new cheerleader girlfriend, or the actually traumatic experience of visualizing Kate lying on the disgusting school bathroom floor, poking herself with a needle? (For a girl who complains about feeling "gross" because she has a disease, she sure didn't seem that horrified to be basically guaranteeing herself an infection of some kind by getting the needle that close to all the bacteria that's definitely partying down there).
These things aside-- though it really is difficult for me to brush off the grammar thing-- the book was okay. The story was not bad, but the execution was. Kate and Aidan/Aiden were both self-absorbed, but what bothers me the most is that Aidan is self-absorbed in a way that makes it seem like he is that way because of how much he ~cares for someone else~ and Kate is self-absorbed in a way that makes you want to slap her. We're supposed to believe that Aidan/Aiden won't go see his sergeant's wife because of how much he thinks he failed him, or her, but in reality he won't go see her because he doesn't want to be reminded of it. Or at least that's what I got out of it. I just-- why attempt to give the male character an excuse for his selfishness, but not the female character? This way it just gives people a reason to blame the girl for the book's failures. People now get to say that she was annoying and whiny and narcissistic (God, what kind of person avoids her problems to the point where she ends up in the hospital? How shallow that she won't consider an insulin tube because of the way it looks! Kate, stop being so horrible and tell him the truth! Stop doing this to your family!), while he was caring and gentle and suffering from his traumatic past (Well, he does think about other people once in a while, so that makes it okay that he doesn't consider that maybe he's not the only person with problems...).

I'm also not entirely sure why this was classified as New Adult, as there wasn't anything any more mature than, say, Twenty Boy Summer or Saving June. Is it because the love interest is-- le gasp-- nineteen? The fragile young readers of YA lit certainly can't handle a nineteen-year-old love interest! He's practically middle-aged!

Sorry, I'm getting into snark territory. I'm just kind of annoyed because this had the potential to be a good novel that brought some diversity to contemporary YA lit (a heroine with diabetes and a hero missing an arm? Two people who aren't physically perfect falling in love? Sure, sign me up), but it was just so poorly executed. I wish the story had been written differently, is all. Disappointing. And usually I would be able to say, "Maybe next time, Author Whose Book Didn't Impress Me This Time," but I can't. I probably will not read Jolene Perry again, after spending four hours wanting to encourage her to take an introductory writing class, or even just teach her the difference between "Let's eat, Grandma!" and "Let's eat Grandma!"
It could have done wonders.
★★☆☆☆